PRICING MODELS
Interchange Plus versus Tiered versus Flat Rate Pricing
The three pricing models bill the same underlying cost in three different ways, and the one that wins for your business depends on your average ticket.
Every quote you have been handed prices the same three costs. Interchange to the issuing bank, assessments to the card network, markup to the processor. What the three pricing models argue about is which of those you get to see and who keeps the difference when the real cost lands lower than expected.
So the honest answer to which model is cheapest is that it depends on your average ticket more than on anything a salesperson says. A business taking 8 dollar sales and a business taking 800 dollar sales can be quoted identical numbers and end up paying rates that are a full point apart. The arithmetic further down shows why.
Interchange plus
Interchange and assessments are passed through at whatever they actually cost, and the processor adds a stated percentage plus a stated amount per sale. A quote reads like a small percentage and a handful of cents.
The reason to want this model is visibility. Your statement can show which interchange categories your volume landed in, so when your bill moves you can see whether the mix of cards moved or the processor moved. It also means a drop in network cost reaches you instead of stopping at the processor.
The parts nobody mentions. Your bill varies month to month, which makes forecasting harder for a business that runs thin. The statement gets long. And pass-through only means pass-through if it is true, so ask whether the network access charges on your statement are billed at cost or padded, and ask for the number in writing.
Tiered pricing
Volume is sorted into buckets. Two buckets on a simple plan, three on the common one, sometimes more. Qualified is the cheap bucket and the number on the front of the proposal. Mid-qualified and non-qualified are the expensive buckets.
Here is the part that matters, and it has nothing to do with the rates. The card networks do not define these buckets. Your processor does. There is no rule anywhere in the network operating regulations that makes a given transaction qualified, which means the sorting is a business decision somebody at your processor is allowed to revisit.
A rewards credit card usually lands in a higher bucket. So does a corporate or purchasing card. So does a sale that was keyed in rather than tapped, or one that settled late, or one that went out missing data the network wanted. If your customers carry the kind of cards that earn points, the rate on the front of your proposal may describe a minority of your volume.
The practical consequence is that a tiered statement cannot be audited. You can see what you were charged. You cannot see what it cost. Those are different questions and only one of them has an answer on the page.
Recognizing the model takes about a minute. Find the page that breaks out your volume. If it lists two or three rate lines with bucket names beside them, you are on tiered pricing. If it lists two dozen category names you have never seen before, you are on pass-through and the long page is the point of it.
Flat rate
One percentage for everything, often with a different rate for keyed or online sales, sometimes with a fixed amount per sale and sometimes without. The processor takes the variance and you take the certainty.
This model gets dismissed too quickly by people who have read one article about interchange. Flat rate is genuinely expensive on regulated debit, where the true cost is low and you pay the same headline number anyway. It is genuinely cheap on a small-ticket business, because the biggest driver of small-ticket cost is the fixed amount per sale, and a flat rate that carries a small one or none at all skips the problem entirely.
Two details inside a flat rate quote are worth pinning down before you sign. The first is the second rate, the one for keyed and online sales, which is higher and which applies to more of your volume than you think if you take phone orders or invoice by email. The second is what happens on a refund. Some providers return the percentage they charged you and some keep it, and on a business that refunds regularly that single policy is worth more than a tenth of a point on the headline number.
Flat rate plans also tend to bundle things the other models bill separately: the gateway, the monthly service charge, the security program fee, the monthly minimum. When you compare a flat rate against an interchange plus quote, you are usually comparing one number against five, and four of them were left off the proposal.
The arithmetic that actually decides it
Take two businesses, both running 40,000 dollars of card volume a month.
The first is a coffee bar with 4,000 sales, so roughly a 10 dollar ticket. The second is a repair shop with 200 sales, so roughly a 200 dollar ticket.
Suppose, purely as an input for this example, that interchange and assessments on their real card mix work out to 1.95 percent of volume plus 12 cents a sale. Suppose the interchange plus quote adds 0.40 percent and 10 cents, and the flat rate quote is 2.60 percent plus 10 cents.
The coffee bar on interchange plus pays 780 dollars in interchange and assessments on volume, 480 dollars in the fixed network and issuer amounts, 160 dollars of percentage markup and 400 dollars of per-sale markup. That is 1,820 dollars, an effective rate of 4.55 percent. The same coffee bar on flat rate pays 1,040 plus 400, which is 1,440 dollars, or 3.60 percent.
Now the repair shop. On interchange plus it pays 780 plus 24 plus 160 plus 20, which is 984 dollars, or 2.46 percent. On flat rate it pays 1,040 plus 20, which is 1,060 dollars, or 2.65 percent.
Same two quotes. Opposite winners. The percentage barely moved the outcome and the fixed amount per sale decided both of them, because 22 cents of fixed cost against a 10 dollar ticket is 2.2 percent of the sale before anyone has charged a percentage at all.
That is the calculation to run before you sign anything, using your own sales count rather than your volume alone.
How to compare two offers without guessing
Ask the incumbent and the challenger for the same thing, and make it specific.
- One real month, restated. Hand over last month's totals and ask each to price that month line by line, including every monthly charge.
- The per-sale amount, separately from the percentage. If a quote gives you a percentage and no per-sale figure, the per-sale figure exists and is simply not on the paper.
- The monthly minimum and what counts toward it. A minimum can quietly erase a better rate on a slow month.
- Your debit share. Pull it from your own reports. Heavy regulated debit volume is the strongest argument against a flat rate, and the strongest argument for looking at how your terminal routes debit.
- The full list of monthly charges. Gateway, security program, statement, batch, account, annual. Whatever is missing from one proposal is the thing that will appear on your first bill.
Then keep the comparison to one page and check it again in six months, because the mix of cards your customers carry is not a fixed thing and the model that won last year may not be winning now.
Common questions
is interchange plus always cheaper than flat rate
No. Interchange plus wins on larger average tickets, because the markup is mostly a percentage and the per-sale charges barely register. On small tickets the fixed per-sale amounts dominate the bill, and a flat rate with a low or absent per-sale charge can easily come out ahead. Run both against one real month of your own sales before you decide.
what does qualified and non-qualified mean on my statement
They are buckets in a tiered pricing plan, and they are defined by your processor rather than by the card networks. Qualified is the cheapest bucket and the rate you were quoted, while mid-qualified and non-qualified are higher buckets that catch rewards cards, corporate cards and transactions missing required data. Nothing in the network rules forces a transaction into one bucket or another, so the assignment is a decision somebody at the processor made.
can my processor change my rate without telling me
Most merchant agreements allow the processor to pass along increases from the card networks, and many also allow a change to your own markup with written notice, where the notice may be a line on the statement you never read. On tiered pricing the processor can also move which transactions land in which bucket, which raises your bill without changing a single quoted rate. Read the change-in-terms clause in your agreement and check the statement pages you usually skip.